Cut, But No Relief: Why Mortgage Rates Stayed Put

The highly anticipated Fed meeting is behind us, and while the Federal Reserve did cut its benchmark rate by 0.25%, mortgage rates actually ticked a bit higher afterward. That might seem confusing, so let’s break down what happened and why the market reacted the way it did.

What the Fed Announced

• The Fed voted to cut the federal funds rate by 0.25%, which was exactly what the market expected.
• They also released their “dot plot,” which shows where they think rates are headed. It pointed to two more potential cuts later this year, likely in November and December.

On paper, both of these developments sounded like good news for lower borrowing costs. So why didn’t mortgage rates drop?

Why the Market Didn’t Rally

This is a classic case of the market “pricing it in.”

In the weeks leading up to the meeting, traders were already expecting this exact outcome.

They had been buying bonds in anticipation, which helped push mortgage rates lower ahead of time. When the Fed delivered what everyone expected, there was no new reason for traders to keep pushing rates lower.

Instead, many took the opportunity to lock in profits from the recent rally, which nudged rates a bit higher. It’s the old saying at work: “Buy the rumor, sell the news.”

What the Fed Said Afterward

Chair Jerome Powell held a press conference after the announcement, and this is where sentiment shifted a bit.

He confirmed that the Fed is currently more focused on the job market than inflation, even though:

• Unemployment is still relatively low, around 4.2%
• Inflation is still running nearly a full percentage point above the Fed’s 2% target
• The economy overall is still growing

That combination puzzled some market watchers. Reporters pressed Powell on why the Fed is cutting rates if slower job growth is tied to immigration (something interest rate cuts won’t affect).

Powell called the decision a “risk management cut” and said they are approaching things on a “meeting-by-meeting” basis.

While that was a reasonable answer, it didn’t come across as very confident. Traders heard caution rather than conviction, and markets responded by pulling back slightly.

Where Things Go From Here

The market still expects two more rate cuts this year, but that outlook could change quickly if hiring picks up or inflation runs hotter than expected. The Fed clearly wants to keep its options open and avoid locking itself into a firm path.

In short, we got the cut that everyone expected, but nothing new enough to push mortgage rates lower. Rates dipped heading into the meeting and then bounced slightly once the news hit.

What This Means for Buyers and Sellers

Mortgage rates are still near the lowest levels we’ve seen all year, but this week was a good reminder that the market moves on expectations, not headlines.

Getting pre-qualified in today’s market can provide a clearer picture of affordability and help secure a stronger position if the right home comes along while rates remain favorable.

If questions come up about what this means for a specific scenario, we’re always happy to talk it through.